I Poured Water on Four Budget Training Pads So You Don’t Have to Clean Up the Mess

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

Some content on this site is AI-assisted and reviewed by our editorial team.

The first time I bought cheap training pads, my beagle mix puppy tiled the kitchen floor. Not a little spill around the edge. I’m talking a full-on river that crept under the baseboards and into the grout lines before I even knew what happened. That was the day I realized “budget” and “actually works” are two very different things, and spending twelve dollars on pads that leak is worse than spending twenty on pads that don’t.

Since then, I’ve gone through more training pads than I care to admit. Puppy training, a senior dog with incontinence, apartment living during a brutal winter where going outside meant freezing paws and refused potty breaks. I’ve tried the expensive brands and the cheap ones, and here’s what I can tell you with certainty: some of the cheapest pads on Amazon are genuinely good, and some are genuinely terrible. The price tag does not tell you which is which.

I picked four of the most popular budget training pads under 15 dollars and put them through what I call the kitchen floor test. I poured measured amounts of water on each one to check absorbency. I pressed paper towels against the surface to see if liquid pooled. I flipped them over to check for leaks through the backing. I left them overnight and checked for odor the next morning. Here’s what I found.

The Four Pads I Tested

1. Amazon Basics Leak-Proof Dog and Puppy Potty Training Pee Pads

This is the pad I recommend to most people, and it’s the one I keep coming back to for my own dog. A hundred pads for well under 15 dollars. Do the math and you’re paying about fourteen cents per pad. That’s hard to beat.

The 5-layer construction is solid. I poured three quarters of a cup of water onto one pad and it absorbed within about ten seconds. The surface was damp but not pooling, which means your dog’s paws stay relatively dry. The waterproof plastic backing held up. No leaks underneath. No seepage at the edges. For the price, the performance is honestly impressive.

Where it falls short is odor control. The pad has no carbon layer, no baking soda, no special odor-neutralizing tech. After eight hours with used pad sitting on my laundry room floor, I could smell it from the hallway. If you work long hours and can’t change pads midday, this is going to bug you. The 22-by-22 inch size is also tight for any dog over about 30 pounds. My beagle mix steps off the edge roughly one out of every three uses.

One thing worth mentioning: I’ve noticed batch inconsistency. My first order felt thick and sturdy. My second order, the pads felt noticeably thinner. Same product, same listing, different experience. Amazon’s return policy covers opened packages, so if you get a dud batch, swap it out.

My take: the smartest spend per pad on this list by a wide margin. Pair it with a pad holder and you’ve got a reliable setup for under 20 dollars total. Just don’t expect it to handle a large dog or an all-day absence without some smell.

Check the current price on Amazon

2. HONEY CARE All-Absorb Dog and Puppy Training Pads

If you live in an apartment or a small space where one used pad can stink up the whole living area, this is the one I’d point you toward. The activated carbon layer is the difference here, and it’s not a gimmick. I left a used pad overnight in my bathroom with the door closed, and the next morning the smell was noticeable but manageable. Compare that to the Amazon Basics pad, which had me opening windows.

Absorbency is comparable to the Amazon Basics. Same 5-layer construction, same 100-count pack, same general price range. The “magic funnel” surface design does seem to pull liquid into the core faster. When I poured water on this one, it disappeared almost immediately. No pooling at all. The paper towel test came up nearly dry on the surface.

The pads measure 22 by 23 inches, which is functionally identical to the Amazon Basics. Don’t expect that extra inch to make any real difference in coverage.

Here’s the downside: these pads run slightly thinner than some alternatives. For a small dog or a puppy, that’s fine. For a heavy wetter or a medium-sized dog, you’ll be changing pads more often. I also noticed that if the pad shifts on a hard floor, the carbon layer can leave a faint dark smudge on light tile. It wipes up easily, but it’s something to be aware of.

My take: Worth the slight premium over basic pads if odor is your priority. The carbon layer genuinely works. Just make sure the pad stays flat and fully unfolded to get the full benefit.

Check the current price on Amazon

3. Simple Solution Training Puppy Pads

This is the absorbency winner. Six layers instead of five. The manufacturer claims each pad holds up to six cups of liquid, so I tested that claim. I poured two cups, waited, poured two more, waited, then poured another. The pad held all six cups without saturating through to the backing. That’s genuinely impressive for a pad in this price range.

The trade-off is quantity. You get 50 pads instead of 100, so the per-pad cost is roughly double the Amazon Basics. But if you have a medium-sized dog or a senior dog who releases a lot at once, fewer changes with better absorbency can actually save you money. I’d rather use one pad that holds up all day than go through three cheaper pads in the same period.

The 23-by-24 inch dimensions give you a touch more surface area than the standard pads. Not enough to matter for a large dog, but enough that my beagle mix stopped stepping off the edge.

One annoyance: these pads slide on hardwood and tile. The plastic backing is smooth, and there’s no grip whatsoever. I ended up putting a thin rubber mat underneath, which solved the problem. You could also use a pad holder, which keeps everything in place and stops dogs from dragging the pad around.

My take: The best choice if absorbency is your main concern. Six layers make a real difference for heavy wetters, senior dogs, or long absences. The higher per-pad cost is justified by the performance.

Check the current price on Amazon

4. Best Pet Supplies XL Puppy Pads

Size. That’s the whole story here. Thirty-six by twenty-eight inches. If you’ve ever watched your large dog try to use a standard pad and step off three out of four paws in the process, you understand why this matters.

I used this pad with a friend’s Labrador during a weekend visit. The dog is about 65 pounds and previously refused to use any pad because they were all too small. This one she used without hesitation. The coverage area is enough that even a dog who walks around while doing their business stays on the pad.

Absorbency per square inch is lower than the smaller pads on this list. The same amount of absorbent material spread over a larger area means each section holds less. For a large dog that produces significant volume, you may still need to change more frequently than you’d like. There’s no carbon layer, so odor control is basic at best.

At 100 pads per pack around the 15-dollar mark, the per-pad cost is excellent for the size. I’ve also used these as crate liners and under food bowls to catch spills. They work well for both purposes.

Here’s a trick I learned: fold the XL pad in half for a large dog that’s a heavy wetter. You get double the absorbent layers in an 18-by-28 inch area, which is still plenty of space for most dogs to stand on. You’re essentially creating a 10-layer pad for pennies.

My take: The only budget option on this list that works for large breeds. If your dog is too big for standard pads, this solves the problem without spending premium money.

Check the current price on Amazon

Which One Should You Actually Buy?

After testing all four, here’s how I’d decide:

You’re training a puppy and going through pads fast: Amazon Basics. The per-pad cost is unbeatable, and the absorbency is good enough for puppies who produce small amounts. Buy two packs at a time so you never run out mid-training.

You live in an apartment or small space: HONEY CARE All-Absorb. The carbon layer keeps odors manageable in tight quarters, and the fast absorbency means less paw tracking across your floors.

You have a medium or senior dog that floods pads: Simple Solution. The 6-layer construction handles volume that the others can’t match. You get fewer pads, but you’ll change them less often.

You have a large dog: Best Pet Supplies XL. It’s the only budget pad on this list big enough for a Lab or Shepherd. Fold it in half for heavy wetters.

If I had to pick just one for general use, I’d go with Amazon Basics. The value is hard to argue with, and for most small to medium dogs, the performance is more than adequate. But I’d keep a pack of the HONEY CARE pads on hand for situations where odor matters more than cost, like when guests are coming over or I’m leaving the dog alone for a full workday.

The Kitchen Floor Test Results

A Few Things I Learned the Hard Way

None of these pads work if your dog won’t use them. All four include a built-in attractant, which helps, but it’s not magic. When I was training my puppy, I placed a small piece of a soiled pad on top of each fresh one for the first week. That transferred her scent and made the connection click. After that, she used the pads without help.

Placement matters more than you’d think. I started with a pad in the kitchen, which seemed logical. Easy to clean floors, close to the back door. But the kitchen is a high-traffic area, and my puppy kept getting interrupted mid-business. She’d stop and finish somewhere else. I moved the pad to a quiet corner of the laundry room, and the accidents dropped dramatically.

If you’re placing pads on hardwood or tile, get a pad holder. I resisted this for months because I didn’t want to spend extra money. Then I spent an afternoon cleaning urine out of grout lines and ordered one that evening. A basic holder costs about eight dollars and saves you from the sliding problem, the dragging problem, and the bunching problem all at once.

Change pads more often than you think you need to. Even the best pad starts to smell after about eight hours of use, and a dog that has to stand on a wet pad will eventually start avoiding it. I change pads first thing in the morning, when I get home from work, and right before bed. Three changes a day keeps the floor clean and the dog cooperative.

When accidents happen outside the pad, and they will, use an enzymatic cleaner. Not bleach, not Windex, not whatever spray you keep under the sink. Enzymatic cleaner actually breaks down the uric acid crystals that dogs can smell long after you’ve wiped the visible mess away. If you skip this step, your dog will keep returning to the same accident spot because the scent marker is still there, even if you can’t smell it.

Never punish your dog for accidents. I know it’s frustrating when you’ve just cleaned the floor and thirty seconds later there’s another puddle. But rubbing a puppy’s nose in it or scolding after the fact doesn’t teach them to use the pad. It teaches them to hide their accidents from you. Positive reinforcement works. Every time your dog uses the pad correctly, make a big deal out of it. Treats, praise, the whole thing. The habit builds faster than you’d expect.

Transitioning From Pads to Outdoors

If your end goal is outdoor potty breaks, training pads are a stepping stone, not a permanent solution. The method that worked for me was gradual. I moved the pad closer to the back door over the course of two weeks. Then I placed a pad just outside the door. Then I removed the pad entirely and started taking my dog out on a schedule instead.

Some dogs get stubborn about pads and refuse to go anywhere else. If that happens, start cutting the pad smaller each day. A smaller pad is less appealing as a potty spot, which nudges your dog toward looking for alternatives, namely the outdoors. Keep outdoor trips rewarding with treats and praise so the transition feels like an upgrade, not a loss.

The Bottom Line

You don’t need to spend a fortune on training pads. All four of the pads on this list will do the job for under 15 dollars, and the differences between them are practical rather than dramatic. Pick based on your specific situation: value for high-volume puppy training, odor control for apartment living, absorbency for heavy wetters, or size for large breeds.

Looking for more budget-friendly gear for your dog? Check out my guides to the best budget dog toys under 15 dollars that actually last and the best budget dog leashes for large dogs under 15 dollars for more smart savings on essentials your dog will love.

ThriftyPaw is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means I may earn a small commission when you buy through links on this page, at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products I believe provide real value to dog owners on a budget.