4 Dog Treats Under 10 Dollars My Dog Actually Goes Crazy For (And One I Threw Away)

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

Some content on this site is AI-assisted and reviewed by our editorial team.

I have a drawer in my kitchen that is full of dog treat bags. Most of them are half-empty. Not because my dog finished them, but because she took one sniff, turned away, and I never reached for them again. Sound familiar?

Over the past few months, I decided to get serious about figuring out which cheap dog treats are actually worth buying. I was tired of spending twelve, fifteen, even twenty dollars on small bags of artisanal jerky that sounded impressive but that my dog treated with the same enthusiasm as a piece of cardboard. I wanted treats under ten dollars. Real ones. Not “under ten dollars if you buy the tiny sample size” — I mean full-size bags that last more than a week.

I ordered a pile of them off Amazon. Some were genuinely great — my dog could not get enough. One was so bad I actually threw it in the trash. Here is what I found, starting with the ones worth your money and ending with the one that is not.

What I Actually Care About in a Cheap Treat

Before I get into the individual reviews, a quick note on what I look for. I am not a dog nutritionist. I am a dog owner who reads ingredient labels and pays attention to how my dog reacts. Here is my personal checklist:

Real meat as the first ingredient. If the first thing on the list is corn or “meat by-product,” I pass. There are plenty of affordable treats that lead with actual chicken, beef, or lamb — you just have to read the bag.

Calories that make sense. My dog is about 30 pounds, and her daily treat budget is roughly 70 calories. A single biscuit that packs 40 calories means I get one treat, maybe two, and then I am done for the day. I prefer treats that let me reward her multiple times without turning her into a chunky dog.

No garbage additives. BHA and BHT are banned in plenty of countries. Artificial colors exist purely so the treat looks pretty to me, not to my dog. Xylitol — sometimes listed as “birch sugar” — is deadly to dogs and still shows up in some peanut butter products. Read the label every time.

Made in the USA when possible. Not a dealbreaker, but I feel better about treats produced under US safety standards. Most of the affordable treats on Amazon are domestic anyway, so this does not usually cost extra.

Price per treat, not price per bag. A ten-dollar bag with 50 treats is twenty cents each. An eight-dollar bag with 20 treats is forty cents each. The sticker price lies. Do the math.

If your dog has a sensitive stomach, you might also want to check out my guide to the best budget dog food for sensitive stomachs — the treats below are meant to complement a good base diet, not replace it.

The Four Treats Worth Buying

Milk-Bone Original Crunchy Medium Dog Treats, 24-Ounce Box

Yeah, I know. Milk-Bones. The most basic treat on the planet. But here is the thing: my dog loves them, and at roughly twelve to sixteen cents per biscuit, the 24-ounce box is genuinely the best per-treat value I have found anywhere.

The box gives you about 50 medium biscuits. They are crunchy, which means they actually do something for her teeth — not a full dental cleaning, obviously, but the scraping action is real. They have added vitamins and minerals, including calcium, which is a nice bonus on top of the treat itself. And they have been made in the USA since 1908, which is longer than most “premium” brands have existed.

Here is my honest take: the ingredient list is not going to impress anyone at a holistic pet store. Wheat flour is the primary base, and there are preservatives in there. If your dog has grain allergies, skip these. But if your dog tolerates grain fine and you want a daily biscuit that costs pocket change, this is the one. I keep a box in the pantry and give my dog one after her evening walk. She has never once turned it down.

One thing I learned the hard way: check the size before you buy. The “medium” size is right for dogs in the 20-to-50-pound range. Too big for a Chihuahua, too small for a Great Dane. Milk-Bone makes small and large sizes too.

Get the Milk-Bone Original Crunchy Medium Dog Treats here

Wellness Soft Puppy Bites, Lamb and Salmon Recipe

I originally bought these for a friend’s puppy, but my adult dog ended up obsessed with them too. These are soft, chewy, and small — roughly the size of a pea — which makes them perfect for training. Real lamb is the first ingredient. Salmon is in there too, which provides DHA, an omega-3 that supports brain development. The recipe is grain-free with no corn, wheat, soy, or artificial anything.

The ingredient quality is honestly better than treats I have paid three times as much for. Lamb and salmon are not cheap proteins, which makes me wonder how Wellness keeps the price under ten dollars. They do it by making the bag small — 6 ounces. That is the tradeoff. You get excellent ingredients, but you do not get a lot of treats.

For training, though, you do not need a lot. These are small enough that one bag still gives you a decent number of repetitions. I used them to teach my dog “place” — sending her to her bed when the doorbell rings. The soft texture means she eats them in under a second and is ready for the next rep immediately. Try doing that with a crunchy biscuit; you spend half the training session waiting for your dog to finish chewing.

One warning: soft treats get crumbly. If you leave these in a coat pocket in warm weather, you will end up with lamb-scented crumbs. Ask me how I know. Keep them in the resealable bag or transfer them to an airtight container.

Get the Wellness Soft Puppy Bites here

Buddy Biscuits Grain-Free Soft and Chewy Dog Treats, Roasted Chicken

This is the treat I reach for when I want to give my dog something that feels like a real reward, not just a training pellet. Buddy Biscuits are soft, chewy, and they smell like actual food. Not chemical-flavored food — real roasted chicken. My dog can hear the bag opening from two rooms away.

The 16-ounce bag is generous. The ingredient list is clean: real roasted chicken, no wheat, corn, soy, artificial colors, or artificial flavors. Oven-baked in the USA. Grain-free and gluten-free, which matters if your dog has sensitivities. At six to nine dollars per bag, the value is solid, especially compared to “premium” grain-free treats that cost twice as much and have similar ingredients.

What I like most is the texture. These are soft enough to tear into quarters for training, but firm enough that they do not fall apart in your hand. I have used them as pill pockets — press a piece around a small tablet and my dog swallows it without noticing. Try that with a Milk-Bone.

The downside? They disappear fast. Soft treats are not “savoring” treats. My dog eats one in about three seconds and looks at me for another. If your dog is a heavy chewer who likes to work on a treat for a while, these will feel like a tease. Also, in hot weather, they can get a bit sticky. I store mine in an airtight container rather than the bag to keep them fresh longer.

If your dog has grain allergies, this is the treat on this list I would point you to first. The combination of clean ingredients, real protein, and a price under ten dollars is hard to beat. For more on managing dental health on a budget, see my guide to budget dog dental care under 20 dollars.

Get the Buddy Biscuits Grain-Free Soft and Chewy Dog Treats here

Fruitables Skinny Mini Dog Treats

Three calories per treat. Let me say that again: three calories. I can give my dog twenty of these in a training session and it adds up to 60 calories, which is under her daily treat budget. That alone makes these worth buying.

But the real reason I love these is the smell. I do not mean “smell” in a bad way. I mean these treats have an aroma that makes my dog lose her mind. I keep a handful in my treat pouch, and she will follow me around the house staring at the pouch for a full hour after a training session is over. The grilled chicken flavor is the one she responds to most, but pumpkin and bacon varieties are available if your dog has different preferences.

The ingredient list is solid: oven-baked, no wheat, corn, or soy, and they use real superfood ingredients. The texture is firm — they do not crumble in your pocket, which is a problem I have had with every other soft training treat I have tried. They stay intact in a treat pouch for hours.

Here is where I am honest about the downside. These are tiny. Like, really tiny. If you have a large breed — a Lab, a Shepherd, a Dane — your dog might swallow these without even chewing. For a 30-pound dog like mine, they are perfect. For a 90-pound dog, they are going to seem like crumbs. I have a friend with a Mastiff who says her dog just looks at her like “that is it?” when she hands over a Skinny Mini.

Also, the flavor intensity varies slightly between batches. I have had bags that smelled amazing and bags that were more subdued. My dog did not seem to care, but I noticed it.

For training, these are my number-one pick. Nothing else on this list lets you reward your dog as many times for as few calories. If you are doing loose-leash work, recall practice, or any high-repetition training, grab these.

Get the Fruitables Skinny Mini Dog Treats here

The One I Threw Away

I said at the top that I ordered a pile of treats, and one was so bad I trashed it. I am not going to name the brand because I am not here to trash a specific company, but I will tell you what was wrong with it so you can spot the same red flags.

The bag cost about five dollars. It had a picture of a happy dog and a big “Real Chicken Flavor” label on the front. I flipped it over and looked at the ingredients. The first ingredient was corn. The second was wheat. The third was “animal digest” — which is exactly as appetizing as it sounds. Chicken was listed seventh, behind three different artificial colors and a preservative I cannot pronounce.

I opened the bag. The treats inside were bright orange, which should have been another clue. I gave one to my dog. She licked it, left it on the floor, and went to lie down. I tried again the next day. Same result. On the third day, I threw the bag away.

Here is the lesson: “real chicken flavor” does not mean real chicken. “Flavor” is a legally distinct term from “made with.” If the first three ingredients are corn, wheat, and something called “animal digest,” your dog is getting a biscuit made of filler with enough artificial flavoring to technically taste like chicken. It costs five dollars because it is worth about five dollars.

Spend the extra two or three dollars and get something with actual meat as the first ingredient. Your dog will be happier, and you will not waste money on treats that end up in the trash.

How I Use These Treats Day to Day

People ask me which single treat they should buy, and my answer is always the same: do not buy just one. Dogs get bored. I get bored. Having variety keeps things interesting for both of us. Here is how I rotate through the four treats above in a typical week.

Mornings, my dog gets a Milk-Bone after her first walk. It is a routine. She sits by the pantry door and waits. The crunch is satisfying for her, and at 12 cents per biscuit, I am not stressed about giving one every day.

Training sessions, I use Fruitables Skinny Minis. Low calorie, strong smell, firm texture. I can do thirty reps of “down-stay” and she still wants more. The fact that they do not crumble in my pouch means I am not leaving a trail of crumbs around the house.

Evenings, I give her a Buddy Biscuit. This is the “you are a good dog and I love you” treat. She gets to chew on something soft and chicken-flavored while I watch TV. I break it in half if she has already had a lot of treats during the day.

The Wellness Puppy Bites I keep for specific situations — working on “place” when guests come over, or any training that needs a higher-value reward than a Skinny Mini but a softer texture than a Milk-Bone. They are also what I bring when I travel with my dog, because the small bag fits easily in a backpack.

A Note on Calories

I mentioned this earlier but it deserves repeating because I see people make this mistake constantly: treats are not free calories. They count toward your dog’s daily intake. If your dog eats 700 calories a day and you give her 150 calories worth of treats, she should get 550 calories of food, not 700. Adjust meal portions on training-heavy days. The 10 percent guideline — treats should not exceed 10 percent of daily calories — is a good rule of thumb that most vets agree on.

Stretching Your Treat Budget

A few things I have learned that make these treats even cheaper over time.

Use Subscribe and Save. Amazon gives you 5 to 15 percent off eligible products when you subscribe, and most of these treats qualify. If you know you are going to buy Milk-Bones every month, set it and forget it. The savings add up, especially if you subscribe to five or more products.

Break treats into pieces. A Buddy Biscuit torn into quarters gives you four rewards from one treat. A Milk-Bone snapped in half gives you two. My dog does not care if she gets a full treat or a piece — she cares that she got something. Breaking treats is the single easiest way to stretch a bag.

Crumble soft treats over food. If your dog is a picky eater, a quarter of a Buddy Biscuit or a Wellness Puppy Bite crumbled over kibble makes the whole meal more interesting. This means you are using treats you already bought instead of buying a separate food topper.

Store them properly. Soft treats go stale in four to six weeks once opened. Crunchy biscuits last longer but still degrade. Keep everything in airtight containers, away from heat and sun. I froze half of my last Buddy Biscuits bag and thawed them a month later — they were fine.

Questions I Get Asked a Lot

Are cheap dog treats safe?

Mostly yes. The treats I reviewed above are all made in the USA and have clean enough ingredient lists. But “cheap” does not automatically mean “safe” — remember the orange filler biscuits I threw away. Safety comes from the manufacturer’s standards, not the price tag. Read the ingredients, look for US-made products, and avoid anything with BHA, BHT, or xylitol.

Can I give my dog multiple types of treats?

Please do. Variety keeps your dog interested and prevents the treat boredom that sets in when you give the same thing every single day. Just track the total calories across all treats. Three different treats in one day still all count toward the same daily budget.

How long do dog treats last?

Most commercial treats have a 12-to-18-month shelf life unopened. Once opened, soft treats stay good for about four to six weeks if sealed properly. Crunchy biscuits last a few months in an airtight container. If the smell changes, the texture changes, or you see any mold, toss them regardless of the date on the package.

Should I be worried about grain-free treats?

The FDA investigated a potential link between grain-free diets and dilated cardiomyopathy in dogs, but that investigation focused on complete grain-free diets, not occasional treats. If your dog eats a normal diet that includes grains, giving a grain-free treat is not a concern. If your dog is on a fully grain-free diet, talk to your vet. For treats specifically, the grain content matters a lot less than the overall diet.

What if my dog is a picky eater?

Strong aroma is the key. Fruitables Skinny Minis smell intense — that is what makes them work for picky dogs. Buddy Biscuits with roasted chicken are another good option. Try warming a soft treat in your hand for a few seconds before giving it to your dog. The heat releases more scent and makes the treat more appealing.

My Honest Take

If I had to pick just one treat from this list, I would go with the Fruitables Skinny Minis. They are the most versatile — low calorie, great smell, firm texture, perfect for training — and they work out to a reasonable per-treat cost. But honestly, the reason I keep all four in rotation is that each one serves a different purpose.

The Milk-Bones are my daily routine treat — cheap, crunchy, reliable. The Wellness Puppy Bites are my high-value training reward — soft, real meat, DHA. The Buddy Biscuits are my “you are a good dog” treat — something she can actually chew and enjoy. And the Fruitables are my training workhorse.

All four cost under ten dollars. All four are made in the USA. And all four have been tested by my dog, who is not shy about telling me when something is not worth eating.

The biggest mistake I see other dog owners make is assuming that price equals quality. It does not. Some of the most expensive treats on Amazon are dressed up in fancy packaging with the same ingredients as the cheap ones. And some of the cheapest treats are genuinely good — real meat, clean labels, dogs that go crazy for them. The trick is reading the label, watching your dog, and being willing to throw away the ones that do not make the cut.

Which I did. And now you do not have to.

FTC Disclosure

ThriftyPaw is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases when you click links on my site and make a purchase on Amazon. This does not affect the price you pay, and it helps me keep producing honest, independent reviews and guides for budget-conscious dog owners. I only recommend products I have researched and believe offer genuine value.