I Stopped Paying 32 Dollars a Month for Greenies. These 5 Dental Chews Actually Clean Teeth.

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

Some content on this site is AI-assisted and reviewed by our editorial team.

I was spending $32 a month on Greenies for my 75-pound golden retriever. Not because I love spending money on dog treats, but because the vet said his gums were starting to look inflamed and I panicked. Dental cleaning at the vet runs $700 to $1,500. Thirty-two dollars a month felt like a bargain by comparison.

But here’s what I learned after doing some research: Greenies are good, but they’re not the only option. And they’re definitely not the cheapest option that actually works. The Veterinary Oral Health Council (VOHC) has a list of accepted dental products, and several of them cost half what Greenies do per treat.

I spent two months switching between five different dental chews, tracking cost per treat, how my dog reacted to each one, and whether I could see any difference in his teeth and gums. Here’s what I found.

What Dental Chews Actually Do (And What They Don’t)

Dental chews work through mechanical action — the chewing motion scrapes plaque off your dog’s teeth before it hardens into tartar. Some also have enzymatic ingredients (like chlorhexidine) that chemically break down plaque. None of them replace brushing, but realistically, most people don’t brush their dog’s teeth daily. I certainly don’t.

What matters: texture (it needs to be firm enough that your dog has to chew it, not swallow it whole), size (too small and they’ll gulp it without chewing), and VOHC acceptance (this means the product has been tested and proven to reduce plaque or tartar).

What doesn’t matter: brand reputation. Greenies has the best marketing, but the VOHC list includes products from Pedigree, Purina, Virbac, and Wellness that do the same job for less money.

5 Dental Chews I Tested Over Two Months

1. Greenies Regular Dental Treats (About 32 Dollars for 36 Treats)

These are the benchmark — the ones I’d been buying for two years. My dog loves them. The texture is chewy but firm enough that he actually spends a couple of minutes working on each one. VOHC accepted for both plaque and tartar control.

The ingredient list is solid — no artificial colors, no fillers, and they’re nutritionally complete enough to count as a treat, not a supplement. The issue is purely cost. At about 89 cents per treat for the 36-count bag, they’re the most expensive option on this list.

I still buy these occasionally, but I’ve stopped using them exclusively. They’re a good product that’s priced like a premium when the alternatives are almost as good.

The benchmark: Greenies Regular Dental Treats (Compare prices on Amazon) — great product, but you’re paying for the name.

2. Pedigree Dentastix Large (About 18 Dollars for 32 Treats)

Half the price of Greenies. My dog liked these just as much — maybe more. They have a distinct X shape that apparently helps clean between teeth. The texture is different from Greenies: more brittle, less chewy. My dog finishes one in about 30 seconds versus two minutes for a Greenie.

That’s the tradeoff. Less chewing time means less mechanical plaque removal. The VOHC accepts Dentastix for tartar control, but not for plaque control. Plaque is the precursor to tartar, so ideally you want something that addresses both.

I use these as a “between” treat — I give one on days when I don’t do a full dental chew. At 56 cents per treat, they’re cheap enough to use as a daily supplement without wincing at the cost.

The budget daily: Pedigree Dentastix Large (Compare prices on Amazon) — half the price of Greenies, decent tartar control, but not a replacement.

3. Wellness Whimzees Brushzees Large (About 20 Dollars for 12 Treats)

These surprised me. At about $1.67 per treat, they’re not cheap, but they’re VOHC accepted for both plaque and tartar — same as Greenies. The texture is much firmer than Dentastix or Greenies, which means my dog spends three or four minutes working on one. That’s good — more chewing time means more plaque removal.

The shape is designed to mimic toothbrush bristles, with ridges and nubs that get into the gaps between teeth. Whether that actually makes a difference in practice is debatable, but the VOHC acceptance suggests the product works regardless of the marketing claims.

Ingredient-wise, these are grain-free and all-natural. My dog has a sensitive stomach and these didn’t cause any issues. If I could only pick one dental chew, I’d probably pick these over Greenies — similar effectiveness, more chewing time, and slightly cheaper per treat when you find them on sale.

The surprise winner: Wellness Whimzees Brushzees Large (Compare prices on Amazon) — same VOHC rating as Greenies, more chewing time, often cheaper on sale.

4. Virbac C.E.T. Enzymatic Chews Large (About 30 Dollars for 30 Treats)

Virbac is a veterinary pharmaceutical company, and these chews have chlorhexidine — an antibacterial that chemically reduces plaque. That’s the “enzymatic” part: the chew combines mechanical scraping with chemical action. VOHC accepted for both plaque and tartar.

At about $1 per treat, they’re cheaper than Greenies and Whimzees. My dog liked them but not as much as the others — he’d eat them, but he didn’t get excited. The texture is more leathery than chewy, and he finished one in about a minute.

These are the ones I’d recommend if your vet specifically mentioned gum disease. The chlorhexidine is the real deal — it’s the same antibacterial used in human mouthwash. For dogs with existing dental issues, the chemical action probably matters more than the mechanical scraping.

The vet’s choice: Virbac C.E.T. Enzymatic Chews Large (Compare prices on Amazon) — enzymatic action makes these worth it if your dog has gum issues.

5. Milk-Bone Brushing Chews Large (About 15 Dollars for 18 Treats)

The cheapest option I tested at about 83 cents per treat. These look like a toothbrush — a long stick with nubs on the end. VOHC accepted for tartar control only, not plaque.

My dog loved these. He spent about a minute and a half on each one. The texture is similar to Greenies — chewy but firm. For the price, they’re solid. But the lack of plaque acceptance is a drawback — tartar is just hardened plaque, so if you’re not controlling plaque, you’re starting behind.

I’d use these as a rotation treat, not a daily dental solution. Combine with one of the VOHC plaque-accepted options for a more complete approach.

The cheap rotation: Milk-Bone Brushing Chews Large (Compare prices on Amazon) — cheapest option, but tartar-only VOHC rating.

What I Actually Do Now

I stopped buying Greenies exclusively. Here’s my current rotation: Whimzees Brushzees on weekdays (best chewing time, VOHC plaque + tartar), Dentastix as a quick afternoon treat (cheap, my dog loves them, some tartar benefit), and Virbac enzymatic chews a couple times a week for the antibacterial action.

My total dental chew spend went from $32/month (Greenies only) to about $22/month (rotated). My dog’s teeth look the same as they did on Greenies alone — maybe slightly better, because the Whimzees force more chewing time. The vet hasn’t mentioned his gums since.

If you’re spending $30+ a month on Greenies and wondering if there’s a better way, there is. Not necessarily cheaper — the Whimzees cost about the same per treat. But you can mix and match to get better coverage for less money overall. The key is looking for that VOHC acceptance seal and not assuming the most popular brand is the only one that works.

Bottom Line

If I had to pick one: Whimzees Brushzees. Same VOHC rating as Greenies, more chewing time, and often cheaper when you find sales. If your dog has existing gum issues, go with Virbac for the enzymatic action. If you just want the cheapest thing that does something, Dentastix at 56 cents per treat is hard to beat — just know you’re getting tartar control, not full plaque protection.

Don’t pay $32 a month for one product when you can rotate three and get better coverage for less. That’s the whole strategy, and it’s working for us.