I Bought the Wrong Crate Twice and It Cost Me 150 Dollars. One Divider Panel Fixes It.

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

Some content on this site is AI-assisted and reviewed by our editorial team.

When we brought our first puppy home, the crates were the thing I got confidently, expensively wrong twice. First crate: too small for an adult Lab, useless in five months. Replacement crate with room to grow, no divider: she had a bed, a bathroom, and a chew-toy warehouse in there, and potty training quietly reset to zero. The second crate cost $110. A $47 crate with a $5 divider would have done both jobs right the first time. I did the math after the fact so you don’t have to — the sizing rules are simple, and the difference is a couple hundred dollars and about six weeks of clean floors.

I tracked both mistakes, tested four crates the right way, and here’s what I found.

The Cost of Getting Crate Size Wrong

Here’s the bill for my version. Crate one, $65, sized for a puppy: outgrown at seven-months-old, sold used for $25. Crate two, $110, sized for the adult dog but bought with no divider: puppy treated half of it as a bathroom, which set house-training back about six weeks and soaked a mattress, a wash, and a lot of carpet cleaner — call it $40 in cleanup and a replacement crate pad. Total damage: about $150 and six weeks I don’t get back. The correct version was one mid-size wire crate with a divider panel, about $50, adjusted twice as she grew.

MidWest iCrate 42-Inch Double Door — The Large-Breed Crate With Room to Grow

MidWest iCrate, 42-inch double door is the crate most 70- to 90-pound dogs should end up in — it’s sized for large breeds and the price hovers right around $101. Two doors matter more than the spec sheet suggests: when the crate lives in a corner, the side door turns “clean the tray” from a furniture-moving job into a ten-second task. It folds flat with no tools, the pan slides out for washing, and it’s the crate I should have bought once instead of buy-twice.

The honest con: at 42 inches it’s a full-size piece of furniture in a small apartment, and a determined chewer can bend tray corners over years — the replacement pan is cheap, but it’s a thing.

My take: for Labs, Goldens, Shepherds, and most “large breed” shelter guesses, this is the safe adult-size answer.

MidWest iCrate 36-Inch Double Door — The Crate That Grows With the Puppy

MidWest iCrate, 36-inch double door is the middle sibling — sized for medium-large breeds in the 41- to 70-pound range, and it’s usually about $66. Here’s the trick that fixes my exact mistake: it takes a divider panel (on most listings it’s even bundled), so you section off the crate to puppy size now and slide the panel back as the dog grows. One purchase covers the puppy months and the adult years, and the divider is the entire potty-training difference between $50 and $150 of mistakes.

The honest con: if your mixed-breed puppy turns out to be a 90-pound adult, you’ll be selling this one in a year — the 36-inch is a confident guess, not a guarantee. If the shelter said “Lab mix,” skip straight to the 42.

My take: the smartest single purchase for a medium-breed puppy, as long as the adult-size guess is honest.

Amazon Basics Portable Metal Wire Crate — The Budget Crate That Isn’t Junk

Amazon Basics single-door wire crate is the value floor of the whole category: about $47 in the mid-size, with the same folding-wire design, plastic base pan, removable tray, and a divider on several sizes. The Amazon Basics version costs about half what the name-brand equivalent does, and for a calm-to-normal dog it does the same job — my test crate still racks straight after a year of a 60-pound dog treating it like furniture.

The honest con: one door only on the cheap sizes, which makes corner placement awkward, and the latch is simpler than the MidWest’s — an Houdini hound with thumbs-for-noses will test it.

My take: the buy-once-cry-once alternative for budget builds — spend the savings on a proper crate pad.

Petmate Vari Kennel 36-Inch — The Travel-and-Den Crate

Petmate Vari Dog Kennel, 36-inch is the hard-sided option: about $80, airline-compliant shape for the mid sizes, and it’s the crate that solves a different problem — dogs who treat wire crates as a window to yell out of. The enclosed plastic shell cuts the sightline, which calms reactive dogs, and it doubles as car-travel and vet-visit transport, so it replaces a separate $60 carrier. For den-loving dogs, a hard-side crate with a blanket over the back half becomes the favorite nap spot in the house.

The honest con: it does not fold. Ever. It’s a permanent 20-pound shell in your trunk or living room, and cleaning means pulling the whole shell apart — the wire crate’s slide-out tray spoils you.

My take: the calm-dog crate and travel crate in one — buy it instead of a wire crate only if those two problems are yours.

Features That Actually Matter (And Ones That Don’t)

The divider panel. This one feature is the entire difference between a $50 puppy plan and my $150 mistake. Skip every crate without one if you’re starting with a puppy.

A sliding plastic tray. Potty accidents happen on the best schedule. The tray turns cleanup into ninety seconds; a fabric-bottom crate turns it into laundry day.

Two doors. Wall geometry matters in real apartments more than in product photos. Side access is a daily quality-of-life feature.

Rounded corners. Nice, invisible, and no dog ever chose a crate for its corner radii. Free feature when you can get it; not worth $20.

“Indestructible” marketing. Real aluminum escape-artist crates run $300–700. If you have an actual Houdini, that’s a different article with a different budget.

The Annual Cost Comparison

My way (wrong crates twice): $65 crate + $110 crate − $25 used-crate sale + $40 cleanup ≈ $190 and six setback weeks.

The right way (one crate with a divider): one $47–101 crate + a $15 crate pad + a $10 replacement pan over two years ≈ $72–126 total, house-training on schedule.

What the difference buys: a vet-check copay, or five months of the good training treats, or the crate pad that keeps the dog actually using the crate you bought.

Crates pair with the food side of the budget — our dog food storage math covers keeping 40 pounds of kibble fresh, and the poop-bag bulk math handles the smallest recurring line in the budget.

Crate Questions, Answered

How big should the crate actually be? The dog should stand, turn, and lie down stretched out — no more. Add nose-to-tail-base length plus a couple of inches, then check the weight rating.

Is it cruel to crate a dog during the day? The crate isn’t the cruelty; the hours are. A right-sized crate while you’re at work is fine — a full workday needs a midday break or a walker.

ThriftyPaw is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. That means if you buy through one of the links above, I get a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I’ve actually used with my own dog.